Game over - I lose
Regardless of the culture from which we hail, there are a few things that tie us together as humans, common threads if you would, that bind us into the adaptable, creative species that we are:
A mother’s touch.
The taste of a good meal.
Money. (I’ll also say maybe beads that one can exchange for other goods and services.)
And that sinking feeling, deep in your gut, that you get when you’re trying to speed across multiple lanes of traffic, you stomp on the gas, only to have the engine stall. You know what I mean. That feeling is closely linked to the warm, wet feeling in your lap as you try to get the car started again before four lanes of oncoming traffic goes all Frogger on your ass.
We have had my lovely wife’s car, the Malibu, in the shop, continuously, since last Wednesday. When we dropped it off, it was stuttering and dying when she applied the gas, usually at the most inopportune moment, such as when merging onto the freeway, or making a left turn across traffic, etc. The problem seems obvious: something is wrong with the fuel delivery system. Whether that’s the fuel filter, or the pump, or a clogged line, or whatever, I’m pretty sure that’s what we’re looking at.
The mechanics and I have a little game we play. They call me up, tell me the car is fixed, and when we get over there to pick it up it won’t start. Or it starts up fine, and then runs until we get to the intersection. Or, our favorite, they call us up and say it won’t stall on them, so they can’t test it. So if we could, just pick it up and bring it back when it’s acting up.
Since when did the world of auto repair become such a crapshoot? When I am having car problems to the point of having to give it to someone else to fix, it’s a pretty safe bet that I don’t know what’s wrong, or how to fix it. Isn’t that what I pay them for? Some of my 65 bucks an hour goes for installation of the parts, but some of it goes towards their experience and service knowledge, right?
It’s like going to the doctor and having him ask “Do you have appendicitis?” right off the bat. How am I supposed to know? What I do know is that it hurts when I do this. You tell me what it means. I think my mechanic likes to pretend he’s House, from that doctor show of the same name. The one where Hugh Laurie plays the brilliant doctor whose cases are always the absolute least-likely diagnosis. Except where House’s patients were bitten by some rare hybrid Tsetse fly, indigenous to one square mile in the southern part of Zambia, my mechanic’s diagnoses are more along the lines of blind guesses, in the hopes that something he’ll pull out of his butt will be correct.
“So, when was the last time you replaced your accelerator tensioner?”
“You mean the spring that pulls the gas pedal up while I push down on it? Never.”
“Yes, that’s the one. Sometimes those go out.”
“Uh huh. And if it did break, wouldn’t the gas pedal fall to the floor, accelerating the car until we couldn’t stop and crashed into something? Yeah, I don’t think that’s the problem.”
“Hmm, okay. Just be careful with that.”
“Will do. Have you checked the fuel filter, pump, lines, etc?”
“We’re working our way that direction.”
Working their way from where, I couldn’t tell you. Obviously it looks to be the gas pedal. I mean, that’s where you press to get the car to move, so why not start there? Or, I know, start at the gas tank door! That’s where the gas goes into the car at the first place, maybe the hole is faulty.
So far, they’ve replaced the entire EGR system (exhaust gas recirculation), the throttle body gasket, Lord knows what else.
I just hope this is one game that I don’t get the high score on.












September 10th, 2007 at 11:01 am
My wife’s last two cars within the first month of getting both the transmissions went out of them.
September 10th, 2007 at 4:22 pm
Wow Jack. She drive for Nascar?
September 10th, 2007 at 5:11 pm
Sounds like a problem with the cylinders to me. At least thats what the problem was when my car did that.
Don’t forget, mechanics are out to make money, specifically your (as a car owner) money. If they can misdiagnose and fix non-broken stuff, they will. I’m sure as an adult you know that, and I believe that is what is happening to you.
September 10th, 2007 at 5:21 pm
You know, I’ve dealt with mechanics before who were definitely out to screw me over, and I just don’t get that vibe from them. What I do get is the impression that unless it’s falling off the bottom of the friggin’ car, they don’t have any idea what’s wrong.
Maybe they’re afraid to just come right out and say “I don’t know.” What we get is “well, it’s hard to tell, ’cause the engine’s not throwin’ any codes…”
It seems to me that the responsibility for diagnosis has shifted and now comes from the car, as opposed to the “certified” mechanic.
September 11th, 2007 at 8:31 am
Yeah, that is totally some distopianism futuristic crap right there. Soon the cars will be fixing themselves, and if you are in the car when that happens you will get all mangled and cut up.
September 13th, 2007 at 10:35 am
I’m with Jason, be wary. Here are four really obvious things any mechanic worth their salt would try in the absence of diagnostic codes:
Fuel line/filter - if it conks out when you accelerate this is usually the cause and it might pull the wool over the diagnostic system.
Ignition System - ditto
Air intake - ditto
Fuel pump - if it’s “lazy” it may be pumping enough gas to go slow and accelerate gently but not for nipping across 4 lanes of heavy traffic! Ditto re diagnostic wool-pulling.
Make them check all three or better still, try a mechanic who knows what they’re doing. Even I know these four and I’m a girl for heavens sake!
Good luck.
Cheers
BC
September 13th, 2007 at 10:36 am
Ok, I can whip the gearbox out of a spitfire and change the clutch but I’m still a girl… and I meant four in the last paragraph there!
Cheers
BC
September 13th, 2007 at 4:07 pm
Well, to wrap it all up, they ended up giving us the car back yesterday. In the end, they couldn’t get the problem to replicate, not after the last time, anyway, and there were no additional charges.
And the car is running fine.
Just one of those things, I guess!